Best Natural Organic Eyeshadows: Natural, Organic and Mineral Eyeshadow and Makeup Brands

If eyeshadow is an essential part of your makeup routine, you know what a difference it can make in your overall appearance.  Eyeshadow can help define your eyes, add a pop of color, pull together a look, and so much more.  As we learn more about how our bodies absorb what we put into our skin and some of the less than appealing ingredients that are used in some makeup, we also begin to realize just how important it is to find a natural eyeshadow.  Natural eyeshadows not only help you look radiant and ready to take on the day (or night), but they also don’t contain any chemicals or substances that could be potentially harmful to your body.  We’ve rounded up some or the best natural organic eyeshadows to help you select the one that will meet, or even exceed, your expectations.

Best Natural Organic Eyeshadows

Ready to learn more about the best natural eye makeup?  Below you’ll find our top picks.  The natural eyeshadow brands featured below are well-trusted in the makeup industry and can help you create a stunning look.

Our Top Pick

Glo Skin Beauty Shadow Palette

Buy on Amazon

Eyeshadow Description

We selected the Glo Skin Beauty Shadow Palette as our top pick for a variety of reasons.

The stunning eyeshadow pallet is both natural-looking and made using safe and natural ingredients.  The palette features eight gorgeous shades of pinks, creams, grays, and tans that can be used to create any look.  You can choose to apply just one color for coverage that is sheer and more natural.  Or, you can use multiple shades for buildable, more intense, color.

Each shade is a high-pigment mineral shadow that has been infused with green tea extract, vitamin C, and vitamin E.  The natural ingredients used to make these eyeshadows can help you feel confident about what you’re putting on your face without compromising your look.

Eyeshadow Reviews

It is not surprising that customers who have tried these natural eyeshadows love them.  Many users have shared that the eyeshadow is easy to apply and goes on smoothly.  They also love that only natural ingredients were used to make these eyeshadows and have shared that they are a great choice for sensitive skin.

Another benefit many people who have tried this eyeshadow pointed to is how beautiful all the colors are.  They love that they are more neutral for a natural look, but also like that they can use multiple shades to build on one another.  Users have found that they can create the perfect look for any occasion.

Pros

• Eight stunning shades are included on the palette.
• The eyeshadow is made using natural minerals and is a good option for sensitive skin.
• You can use one shade at a time, or choose multiple shades to build your coverage.

Cons

• This palette is more expensive than many other options.

Best Organic and Non-Toxic Eyeshadow

Antonym Certified Organic Eyeshadow Quattro

Buy on Amazon

Eyeshadow Description

The Antonym Certified Organic Eyeshadow Quattro is designed to be used on all skin types, including sensitive skin.  This organic eye makeup quattro includes four stunning shades to help you perfect your look.  There are two different color palette options to choose from.  The first choice, Croisette, includes beige, black, nude, and brown.  The second choice, To The Moon & Black, includes bronze, mauve, gray, and white.

This natural eyeshadow has a very smooth formula that is easy to apply.  Light accentuating pigments were added to the formula to give more depth and radiance to your look.  Another benefit of this eyeshadow is how versatile it is.  The four color choices can be used to highlight, line, or shade your eye.

The formula for this eyeshadow is natural and organic, so you don’t have to worry about what gets absorbed into your skin.  It is also paraben-free and vegan.

Eyeshadow Reviews

This organic vegan eyeshadow palette is quite popular with people who have tried it.  Many consumers shared how easy it was to apply this eyeshadow.  They also shared that they think the different shades are gorgeous and true to online images.  Many also said that they were able to blend the colors together nicely to create a unique and customized look for their eyes

Customers were also very happy knowing that this is an organic and chemical-free eyeshadow.  They love being able to apply eyeshadow and perfect their look without worrying about harmful substances getting absorbed by their skin.

Pros

• This organic eyeshadow palette is also vegan and paraben-free.
• The eyeshadow is easy to apply and blend to customize your look.
• There are two different shade combinations to choose from.

Cons

• You won’t receive as many different shades as you would with some other eyeshadow palettes.

Best Natural-Looking Eyeshadow

Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Eyeshadow Palette

Buy on Amazon

Eyeshadow Description

The Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Eyeshadow Palette is an absolutely lovely option to consider.

There are four different palette options to choose form:  Blooming Desert, Countryside Lavender, Dusky Woods, and Shimmering Nudes.  Each palette includes three different shades inspired by nature.  The shades get progressively darker within each palette and can be blended together to highlight and accentuate your eyes.  A subtle shimmer is added to each eyeshadow to help further accentuate your eyes and draw attention to them, while still enjoying a natural-looking eyeshadow.

This all natural eyeshadow palette was made using rich minerals.  You’ll be impressed with how easy the eyeshadow is to apply and how long it will last.  It is also designed to resist smudging, creasing, or fading, so you’ll continue looking your best all day long.

Another benefit of this eyeshadow is that it is made using only natural ingredients.  Some of these natural ingredients include honey, vitamins, and bamboo.  These safe and natural ingredients also make this eyeshadow palette a great option for individuals who have sensitive skin or wear contact lenses.  No parabens, phthalates, petrolatum, talc, silicone, SLS, or synthetic fragrances were used to make the eyeshadow.  Ophthalmologist have tested the eye shadow, and Burt’s Bees never tests their products on animals, which should help you feel more comfortable giving it a try.

Eyeshadow Reviews

This is a highly popular choice for people who are looking for natural eyeshadow.  Customers overwhelmingly recommend it to others because of how it feels on their skin and the fact that it does not irritate sensitive skin.  They have also shared that they love the natural colors and how easy it is to blend the shades together to fine-tune their look.

The compact for this palette is also a bit smaller than some other options, which many consumers said they like.  It is the perfect size to toss in your purse so you’ll have your eyeshadow on hand for touch ups when you’re out.

Pros

• This 100% natural eyeshadow is very reasonably priced.
• There are four different color palettes to choose from.
• Burt’s Bees does not test their makeup products on animals.

Cons

• There are only three shades in each palette.

Best Mineral Eyeshadow

Youngblood Pressed Mineral Eyeshadow Quad

Buy on Amazon

Eyeshadow Description

With seven different color palettes to choose from, you’ll be able to find the right colors for your skin and the look you’re after with Youngblood’s Pressed Mineral Eyeshadow Quad.  Each palette includes four different shades in a mix of matte, pearly, and shimmery finishes.  These four shades are designed to be easily blendable to allow everyone to personalize their eye makeup and even change things up depending on where they are going.

This is one of the best mineral eyeshadows. Youngblood uses a pressed mineral formula that is designed to be easy to apply, silky, and long-lasting.  Jojoba oil and vitamin E are also included in the formula for these eyeshadows.  The added vitamin E will help nourish your skin and protect it from free radicals, and the jojoba oil will offer beneficial hydration

This eyeshadow is a cruelty-free product and does not include any talc or parabens.

Eyeshadow Reviews

Individuals who have tried this eyeshadow rave about how smoothly it goes on and how comfortable it is to wear all day long.  They also love that once they apply their eyeshadow it will stay and continue looking great until they remove it.

Many users also shared how pleased they were with the color selections.  They felt that the colors in each palette really complemented each other nicely and helped them bring their visions to reality when applying their makeup.

Pros

• There are seven different color palettes to choose from.
• The pressed mineral formula goes on smoothly and lasts all day.
• Jojoba oil is added to the formula to help hydrate your skin.

Cons

• This is not an organic eyeshadow.

Best Vegan Eyeshadow

MCo Beauty Vegan Eyeshadow Makeup Palette

Buy on Amazon

Eyeshadow Description

The MCo Beauty Eyeshadow Makeup Palette is an option for you to consider if finding a vegan natural eyeshadow is important to you.  There are two different palette options for you to choose from:  Smokey Nudes and Nude Shades.  Each palette features nine different shades in a mix of matte and satin finishes.  You can blend the shades together to create a unique look to match your personality and desires.

One key benefit of these eyeshadows is that they are formulated to last all day; you won’t find that you’re constantly touching up your eye makeup.  Each palette is designed to be used by individuals with all skin tones.  In addition to being vegan-certified, this eyeshadow is also cruelty-free.

Eyeshadow Reviews

Customers who have purchased this eyeshadow love that it is very reasonably priced while still being a quality eyeshadow.  Users have also shared that the colors are gorgeous and nicely pigmented.  They say they blend well together, but also look great by themselves.  The eyeshadows also have a hint of sparkle; customers liked how the sparkle drew some extra attention to their eyes without being too flashy.

Pros

• This vegan eyeshadow has a blendable formula that goes on smoothly.
• Compared to other options, this eyeshadow is very inexpensive.
• The colors can be worn on their own or blended together.

Cons

• The powder is a little loose, so it may get on your clothes or other parts of your face as you apply your eyeshadow.

Best Natural Liquid Eyeshadow

Perricone MD No Makeup Eyeshadow

Buy on Amazon

Eyeshadow Description

If you have been searching for a liquid eyeshadow, you’ll definitely want to consider the Perricone MD No Makeup Eyeshadow.  This eyeshadow is designed to help you achieve a natural look and make it appear that you are hardly wearing any makeup at all.  The formula includes light reflecting pigments that will help perfect the look of your eyelids; they’ll have a soft and satin-like finish.  You can choose to use this liquid eyeshadow alone, or it can be used as a primer to create the perfect base for adding another eyeshadow.

In addition to working as an eyeshadow, this liquid also delivers benefits to your skin.  It can help revitalize aging eyes and reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles.  Acyl-Glutathione is added to the formula to help brighten eyes.  The formula is also crease-proof, so it will keep your eyes looking amazing all day.

Eyeshadow Reviews

Makeup users who have tried this liquid eyeshadow love that it can be used alone when they’re trying to create a more natural look, or as an eyelid primer when they want to add to their look.  They are also pleased with how well the eyeshadow works to hide imperfections or signs of aging.  They also say that it goes on smoothly and feels comfortable to wear all day.

Pros

• You can use this eyeshadow alone for a natural look or as an eye primer beneath your other eye makeup.
• It can help brighten eyes and reduce the signs of aging.
• The eyeshadow has a crease-proof formula.

Cons

• Depending on your skin tone, the color may not be the right match.

Best Natural Eyeshadow Palette

Milani Most Loved Mattes Eyeshadow Palette

Buy on Amazon

Eyeshadow Description

If you’re looking for an eyeshadow palette that will provide you with an endless number of color combinations and blending options, take a look at the Milani Most Loved Mattes Eyeshadow Palette.  This palette includes 12 breathtaking shades to help you create everything from a subtle and natural look to a vibrant and  jaw-dropping look.

You can choose to wear one of the shades by itself, or blend two or more shades together.  If you’re going to create a blended look, start by applying the lightest shade over your eyelid.  Then add the medium shade to your eye’s crease, and finally, blend the darkest shade along your lash line.

This eyeshadow palette comes in a compact with a mirror; this will make it easy to bring along with you if you’ll be touching up your makeup when you’re out or applying a fresh coat before leaving work and meeting up with friends.

Milani does not test any of their products on animals.  This eyeshadow has also been certified as cruelty-free by PETA.

Eyeshadow Reviews

One thing that many users have shared about this eyeshadow palette is that they love how well it performs for its very reasonable price.  Many said that they find this eyeshadow comparable to higher priced ‘designer’ options.  Users are also very happy with the large selection of colors that are included in the palette.  They love being able to customize their look for different occasions.

Users have also shared how easy it is to apply the eyeshadow and blend it.  They also like that the compact has a large mirror that makes it possible to apply their makeup when they’re away from home.

Pros

• 12 blendable shades are included in the palette.
• There is a large mirror in the compact for applying your eyeshadow when you’re away from home.
• PETA certified this eyeshadow as cruelty-free.

Cons

• Some users feel that some of the shades aren’t pigmented enough and don’t last.

Best Cruelty Free Single Eyeshadow

RMS Beauty Certified Organic Eyeshadow

Buy on Amazon

Eyeshadow Description

The RMS Beauty Certified Organic Eyeshadow in Twilight Madness is a smoky and shimmery gray color which can be used to help you get ready for a night out.  Gray and black hues are incorporated into this eyeshadow that is inspired by television shows from the 1960s.  You have the option to apply this eyeshadow wet or dry.  If you apply it wet, it will help give your eyes a smoky gleam.  When it is applied dry, this eyeshadow is buildable to help you create your ideal look.

RMS designed this organic pressed eyeshadow to be easy to apply.  You can use a sponge-tip applicator or a makeup brush to apply it to your eyelids.  Only food-grade organic ingredients and minerals were used in making this eyeshadow.  Its base includes organic buriti fruit oil, mica, and naturally derived silica.  The formula does not include soy, RBD products, GMOs, nanos, or any other harmful chemicals.  RMS never tests their makeup products on animals.

Eyeshadow Reviews

This eyeshadow is highly reviewed among users who have tried it.  They love the color and the different application options that are available.  Customers have also shared that they are happy that the ingredient list doesn’t include anything questionable that they wouldn’t want to put on their skin or in their bodies.

Pros

• The eyeshadow can be applied wet or dry.
• It is made using only organic ingredients and does not contain any harmful chemicals.
• RMS does not test makeup on animals.

Cons

• Depending on your preferences, you may find that this eyeshadow is too shimmery.

What Does Natural Eyeshadow and Eye Makeup Mean?

Before you’ll be able to select the best natural eyeshadow for you, it is important to understand what the word “natural” really means.  When it relates to eyeshadow and makeup products, there are three different ways you may see the word natural used.

One way the word natural is used is to refer to eyeshadows that are made using non-toxic or organic materials.  While the FDA hasn’t developed a formal definition for organic, the USDA has established a set of criteria that must be met for something to be labeled as organic  Plants must be grown in soil that has not been treated with any prohibited substances, such as synthetic pesticides or fertilizers, for at least three years.

Natural eyeshadows and other makeup products are often referred to as “clean beauty” items.  This label lets individuals know that they are purchasing an item that is non-toxic and should be safe to use on their skin.  You may also find some natural eyeshadows that are labeled “vegan” or “vegan-friendly.”  Vegan eyeshadows are made without using any ingredients derived from animals.  Honey, animal fats, or crushed insects are sometimes included in the ingredient list for non-vegan makeup items.

Another meaning of the word natural as it relates to eyeshadow is natural-looking or natural finish.  Natural-looking eyeshadows are more toned down and subtler than brighter or more colorful options.  When applied, they’ll blend in with your skin tone to give the illusion that you really aren’t wearing much makeup.

A natural eyeshadow may be your go-to eyeshadow, or it may be the one you choose for certain events or occasions, such as going to the office.  You may also decide that it is fun to switch up your look from time to time and enjoy having a natural eyeshadow ready whenever you decide you want to use it.

Sometimes natural eyeshadow can also refer to mineral eyeshadows.  To make these eyeshadows, natural minerals like talc, iron oxides, zinc oxides, and titanium dioxide are very finely ground.  These minerals have different colors and tones and can be used to create eyeshadows and other natural makeup items.  Unlike other eyeshadows on the market, mineral eyeshadows are typically made without any waxes, oils, or preservatives.  If you have sensitive skin, mineral eyeshadows may be an excellent choice since they also don’t contain any fragrances, which often irritate sensitive skin.

One key benefit of choosing mineral eyeshadows and other mineral makeups is that they also function as a protective sunscreen.  The zinc oxide and titanium dioxide in mineral eyeshadows can provide some SPF protection from the sun.

Best Natural Organic Eyeshadows: A Summary

Here are the top 8 best natural organic eyeshadows:

1. Glo Skin Beauty Shadow Palette 
2. Antonym Certified Organic Eyeshadow Quattro
3. Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Eyeshadow Palette
4. Youngblood’s Pressed Mineral Eyeshadow Quad
5. MCo Beauty Eyeshadow Makeup Palette
6. Perricone MD No Makeup Eyeshadow
7. Milani Most Loved Mattes Eyeshadow Palette
8.  RMS Beauty Certified Organic Eyeshadow

When creating that natural beauty look, a natural eyeshadow is a must.  Natural and organic eyeshadows are much healthier for your skin than other options on the market.  When you use a natural eyeshadow , you can feel confident that you aren’t introducing any toxic or harmful substances into your body or bloodstream.

We hope our reviews of the best organic eyeshadows has helped you get excited about trying a new eyeshadow.  After you add that new non-toxic eyeshadow to your cart, don’t forget about other eye makeup you may need too.  If you’re looking for the perfect mascara for long lashes, our post will help you find the best option to meet your needs.